A Critical Perspective of "Subjective Value" According to the CJEU to Determine the VAT Taxable Amount in Barter Transaction - A New Solution

Authors

  • Wei Zhang Doctoral Student. University of Linz, Austria

Abstract

The decisions made by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in respect of the Value Added Tax (VAT)-taxable value of barter transactions (consideration in kind) (van Doesum et al., 2016) in cases where the consideration has no market price (one-time and unusual service) have been considered to be incompatible with Article 73 of the VAT Directive (see Englisch, 2021b; HMRC, 2021). The CJEU has justified this incompatibility by introducing the term “subjective value”. Before 2018, the Bundensfinanzhof (BFH)— the German Federal Fiscal Court—followed these CJEU judgments by referring to “subjective value” and referring to Section 162 of the Abgabenordnung (AO)—the German General Fiscal Code—thus producing a solution compliant with the law. In 2018, the BFH waived its position and went in an incorrect direction. The view of the U.K.’s H.M. Revenue & Customs (HMRC) department is that the question “has not been considered by the VAT Tribunals or Courts and that any cases of this kind should be submitted to the VAT Supply team” (HMRC, 2021). From a predominantly German perspective, the author demonstrates that the “subjective value” is not a satisfactory solution and suggests, de lege ferenda, the introduction of a new Article 42a into Council Implementing Regulation (EU) No 282/2011 as a new solution by which to ascertain the taxable amount in barter transactions in cases where the consideration has no market price.

References

Auer, D., Siller, S., Spies, K., & Zolles, S. (2019). EuGH-Rsp zur Umsatzsteuer: Die Bemessungsgrundlage bei Tauschgeschäften. [ECJ-case on VAT: The assessment basis for barter transactions]. ecolex 2019, VwGH v. 28.3.1958, Zl.1500/57 [the Austrian Supreme Administrative Court of March 28, 1958, Zl.1500/57].

Berger, W., Toifl, C., & Wakounig, M. (2018). Mehrwertsteuersystemrichtlinie: Praxiskommentar. [COUNCIL DIRECTIVE 2006/112/EC on the common system of value added tax: Practice commentary]. Vienna, Austria: LexisNexis.

Court of Justice of the European Union. (2022). InfoCuria: Case-law. https://curia.europa.eu/juris/recherche.jsf

Englisch, J. (2021a). Europäisches Steuerrecht. [European tax law]. In Tipke, K., Lang, J., Seer, R., Reiss, W., Hey, J., Montag, H., & Englisch, J. (Eds.), Steurrecht [Tax Law] (24th ed., pp. 157-217). Cologne, Germany.: Dr. Otto Schmidt.

Englisch, J. (2021b). Kapitel 17 Umsatzsteuer. [Value added tax]. In Tipke, K., Lang, J., Seer, R., Reiss, W., Hey, J., Montag, H., & Englisch, J. (Eds.), Steurrecht [Tax Law] (24th ed., pp. 1037- 1267). Cologne, Germany: Dr. Otto Schmidt.

European Union (2012a). Consolidated version of the treaty on European Union. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/resource.html?uri=cellar:2bf140bf-a3f8-4ab2-b506-fd71826e6da6.0023.02/DOC_1&format=PDF

European Union. (2012b). Consolidated version of the treaty on the functioning of the European Union. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:12012E/TXT&from=EN

Federal Ministry of Justice. (n.d.). The fiscal code of Germany. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_ao/englisch_ao.html

Gunacker-Slawitsch, B. (2015). Eigenverbrauch und normalwert – Ausgewählte fragen. [Own consumption and normal value – selected questions]. In M. Achtz & M. Trumple, Die Bemessungsgrundlage der umsatzsteuer [The assessment basis of the sales tax] (pp. 137- 167). Vienna, Austria: Linde Verlag.

H. M. Revenue & Customs. (2016, April 26). HMRC internal manual: VAT valuation manual: VATVAL06000 – Non-monetary consideration: barter transactions – valuation when one or both supplies have no clear value. https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/vat-valuation/vatval06000

H. M. Revenue & Customs. (2021, May 12). HMRC internal manual: VAT valuation manual: VATVAL05900 - Non-monetary consideration: barter transactions - valuation when each supply has a different value. https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/vat-valuation/vatval05900

Kirchhof, P. (1987). Die Bestimmtheit und Offenheit der Rechtssprache: Vortrag gehalten vor der Juristischen Gesellschaft zu Berlin am 29 April 1987. [The certainty and openness of legal language: Lecture given to the Berlin Legal Society on April 29, 1987]. Berlin, Germany: Walter de Gruyter.

Kolozs, B. (2009). Neutrality in VAT. In M. Lang, P. Melz, & E. Kristoffersson (Eds.), Value added tax and direct taxation: Similarities and differences (pp. 201-212). Amsterdam, The Netherlands: IBFD.

Korn, C. (2019). Grundtatbestand: Entgeltliche Leistung. [Basic facts: Paid service]. In J. Bunjes (Ed.), Umsatzsteuergesetz [Value Added Tax Act] (21th ed.). Munich, Germany: C. H. Beck.

Lippross, O-G. (2017). Bemessungsgrundlage beim tausch. [Assessment basis for the exchange]. Umsatzsteuer-Rundschau [VAT Review], 66(21-22), 821-826. https://doi.org/10.9785/ur-2017-21-2203

Muehlehner, J. (1994). Umsatzsteuer und EU-Beitritt [VAT and EU accession]. Steuer- und WirtschaftsKartei (SWK) [Tax and Economic Index], 25, 554-556.

Pfister, P. (2015). Zahlungsmodalitäten. [Payment arrangements]. In M. Achatz & M. Tumple (Eds.), Die Bemessungsgrundlage der umsatzsteuer [The assessment basis of the sales tax], (pp. 29-59 ). Vienna. Austria: Linde Verlag.

Probst, U. (2019). Bemessungsgrundlage für Lieferungen, sonstige Leistungen und innergemeinschaftliche Erwerbe. [Basis of assessment for deliveries, other services and intra-community acquisitions]. In A. Hartmann & W. Metzenmacher (Eds.), Umsatzsteuerrecht [Value Added Tax Law] (pp. 1-218). Berlin, Germany: Erich Schmidt Verlag GmbH & Co. KG.

Reiß, W. (2018). Der „subjektive wert der gegenleistung“ als bemessungsgrundlage für den eigenen Umsatz? [The “subjective value of the consideration” as a basis for assessing one's own turnover?]. UmsatzsteuerRundschau [VAT Review], 67(21), 822-831. https://doi.org/10.9785/ur-2018-672103

Reiß, W. (2019). Die steuerbemessungsgrundlage bei tauschvorgängen. [The tax base for barter transactions]. UmsatzsteuerRundschau [VAT Review], 68(8), 281-288. https://doi.org/10.9785/ur-2019-680802

Rothenberger, F. (1995). Anmerkung in „bemessungsgrundlage bei werbung von kunden durch kunden grundsatz subjektiver wertbemessung – Wert der gegenleistung (werbegeschenk) für Kundenzuführung. [Note in “Assessment basis when advertising customers through customers, principle of subjective value assessment - value of the consideration (advertising gift) for customer feed”]. Umsatzsteuer Rundschau [VAT Review], 2, 64-66.

Ruppe, H. G., & Achatz, M. (2018). Umsatzsteuergesetz – Kommentar. [Value Added Tax Act – Commentary] (5th ed.). Vienna: Facultas Verlags- und Buchhandels AG.

Schenk, A., Thuronyi, V., & Cui, W. (2015). Value added tax: A comparative approach. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

Spilker, B. (2019). BFG zum tauschähnlichen Umsatz bei der Überlassung von “Pressefahrzeugen” [BFG on barter-like sales for the provision of “press cars”]. Steuer- und WirtschaftsKartei (SWK) [Tax and Economic Index], 16, 731-733.

Stadie, H. (2009). Umsatzsteuergesetz: Kommentar. [Value Added Tax Act: Commentary]. n.p.: Dr. Otto Schmidt.

Stapperfend (2021). Bemessungsgrundlage für lieferungen, sonstige leistungen und innergemeinschaftliche erwerbe. [Basis of assessment for deliveries, other services and intra-community acquisitions]. In G. Rau & E. Dürrwächter (Eds.), Umsatzsteuergesetz Kommentar [Value added tax: Comment] (pp. 1-170). Cologne, Germany: Dr. Otto Schmidt.

Terra, B., & Kajus, J. (2017). A guide to the European VAT Directives: Introduction to European VAT (Vol. 1). Amsterdam, The Netherlands: IBFD.

Treiber, A. (2021). Bemessungsgrundlage für Lieferungen, sonstige Leistungen und innergemeinschaftliche Erwerbe. [Basis of assessment for deliveries, other services and intra-community acquisitions]. In O. Sölch & K. Ringleb (Eds.), Umsatzsteuergesetz- Kommentar, 2019 [Value Added Tax Act Commentary, 2019] (pp. 1-110). Munich, Germany: C. H. Beck.

Van Doesum, A., van Kesteren, H. W. M., & van Norden, G-J. (2016). Fundamentals of EU VAT law. The Hague, The Netherlands: Kluwer Law International.

Windsteig, K. (2015). Steuerbare umsätze (Taxable transactions). In S. Melhardt & M. Tumpel (Eds.), Umsatzsteuergesetz-Kommentar [VAT law comment] (2nd ed., pp. 3 - 131). Vienna, Austria: Linde Verlag.

Volume 7.2 of JOTA - Zhang Cover

Downloads

Published

31-12-2022

How to Cite

Zhang, W. (2022). A Critical Perspective of "Subjective Value" According to the CJEU to Determine the VAT Taxable Amount in Barter Transaction - A New Solution. Journal of Tax Administration, 7(2), 153–183. Retrieved from https://journals.docuracy.co.uk/jota/article/view/27